Missing trial data threatens the integrity of medicine

Missing clinical trial data can harm patients and lead to futile costs to health systems, warn experts as part of an in-depth BMJ review of the matter. Missing data is a serious problem in clinical research. It distorts the scientific record, so that clinical decisions cannot be based on the best evidence.

BMJ publishes several papers that examine the extent, causes, and consequences of unpublished evidence. They confirm that a large proportion of evidence from human trials is unreported, and much of what is reported is done so inadequately.

In an editorial, Dr Richard Lehman from the University of Oxford and BMJ Clinical Epidemiology Editor, Dr Elizabeth Loder, describe a "culture of haphazard publication and incomplete data disclosure." They call for more robust regulation and full access to raw trial data to allow better understanding of the benefits and harms of many kinds of treatment.

A study by Beth Hart and colleagues finds that including unpublished data in published meta-analyses of drug trials often changed their results. They argue that access to full trial data is needed to allow drugs to be independently assessed.

Two further studies show poor adherence to requirements for mandatory trial registration and timely sharing of results. Ross and colleagues show that fewer than half of US National Institutes of Health funded trials are published in a peer reviewed journal within 30 months of completion, while Andrew Prayle and colleagues find that only 22% of trials subject to mandatory reporting had results available within one year of completion.

"When the word 'mandatory' turns out to mandate so little, the need for stronger mechanisms of enforcement becomes very clear," write Lehman and Loder.

Other studies published today highlight the many difficulties researchers face when they try to assess the true harms and benefits of common interventions.

Lehman and Loder believe that concealment of data is "a serious ethical breach" and that clinical researchers who fail to disclose data "should be subject to disciplinary action by professional organisations."

They conclude: "These changes have long been called for, and delay has already caused harm. The evidence we publish shows that the current situation is a disservice to research participants, patients, health systems, and the whole endeavour of clinical medicine."

Most Popular Now

Pfizer announces positive top-line results from Ph…

Pfizer Inc. (NYSE: PFE) today announced positive top-line results from the Phase 3 BENEGENE-2 study (NCT03861273) evaluating fidanacogene elaparvovec, an investigational ...

VidPrevtyn Beta COVID-19 booster vaccine, develope…

GSK plc (LSE/NYSE: GSK) has announced the United Kingdom's Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) authorised Sanofi's SARS-CoV-2 spike protein (B.1.35...

Time-restricted eating reshapes gene expression th…

Numerous studies have shown health benefits of time-restricted eating including increase in life span in laboratory studies, making practices like intermittent fasting a ...

Incurable liver disease may prove curable

Research led by Associate Professor Duc Dong, Ph.D., has shown for the first time that the effects of Alagille syndrome, an incurable genetic disorder that affects the li...

Scientists develop a cancer vaccine to simultaneou…

Scientists are harnessing a new way to turn cancer cells into potent, anti-cancer agents. In the latest work from the lab of Khalid Shah, MS, PhD, at Brigham and Women’s ...

AstraZeneca to acquire CinCor Pharma to strengthen…

AstraZeneca has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire CinCor Pharma, Inc. (CinCor), a US-based clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company, focused on developing no...

COVID-19 vaccines, prior infection reduce transmis…

Vaccination and boosting, especially when recent, helped to limit the spread of COVID-19 in California prisons during the first Omicron wave, according to an analysis by ...

NextPoint Therapeutics announces $80 million Serie…

NextPoint Therapeutics, a biotechnology company developing a new world of precision immuno-oncology, announced today that it raised $80 million in Series B financing co-l...

Enzyme that protects against viruses could fuel ca…

An enzyme that defends human cells against viruses can help drive cancer evolution towards greater malignancy by causing myriad mutations in cancer cells, according to a ...

Nanotechnology may improve gene therapy for blindn…

Using nanotechnology that enabled mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, a new approach to gene therapy may improve how physicians treat inherited forms of blindness. A collabo...

Bayer to accelerate drug discovery with Google Clo…

Bayer AG and Google Cloud announced a collaboration to drive early drug discovery that will apply Google Cloud's Tensor Processing Units (TPUs), which are custom-develope...

Study identifies potential new approach for treati…

Targeting iron metabolism in immune system cells may offer a new approach for treating systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) - the most common form of the chronic autoimmune...